Reynolds: it’s almost like screw the Orioles by the umpires

Orioles manager Buck Showalter and first baseman Reynolds were ejected after a call on Tigers shortstop Jhonny Peralta was reversed, ruling Reynolds’ foot to be off the bag. The initial ruling by first-base umpire Jeff Kellogg was out but, the call was overturned several moments later after Peralta argued and Kellogg conferred with home-plate umpire Tim Timmons.

Reynolds spiked his glove and was immediately ejected, then was pushed aside by an angry Showalter, who was also tossed. Reynolds didn’t hold back in his post-game interview. Here’s what he said..

[on the play] “First of all, Manny made a hell of a play. Tough throw and I stayed on the bag and that’s why I got so upset.  I don’t understand how an umpire can miss a play at home plate that’s right in front of him and see that play from home plate at first base.  It’s embarrassing that they would overturn a call that obviously has an impact on the game in the middle of the pennant race. Obviously by the way I acted, it’s very frustrating. I’ve never seen it in my life an umpire reverse a call after the right call is made. And it’s obviously on the replay I kept my foot on the bag. I was pretty mad.”

[shocked?] “Definitely. I’ve never in my life seen someone reverse a call. The guy in Colorado, the guy was off the bag by three feet. And my foot was on the bag and they reversed it. And it’s a shame they don’t have accountability. They don’t have any, if they make a bad call it’s like, ‘Ho-hum, next day is coming.’ If we have a bad couple of games we get benched or we get sent down. They have nobody breathing down their throats. They have nobody, they are just secure in their jobs. And they are probably over there right now laughing about it because they don’t worry about it.  This game is way too important right now, where we are in the season, for these kind of calls to happen. And it’s very frustrating.”

[on being ejected after spiking his glove] “That’s terrible. Vic [Carapazza] has no authority to throw me out right there. all I did was an equipment violation, it’s a fine. You are supposed to point at it and the league offices decide what to do there. He just threw me out right there. I didn’t do anything wrong. If I go up to him and say something to him, that I shouldn’t say. That’s fine, throw me out there for that. But you can’t throw me out for throwing my glove. What’s the difference between a guy throwing his helmet after a bad call? It’s just part of it and everybody goes on their way. He had no right to throw me out there. There’s just so many words I can’t say on this camera right now.”

[on how tough this was to handle] “It’s almost like screw the Orioles by the umpires. I mean Jonsie was obviously safe at first base the other day, cost us a run against Boston. There’s got to be some kind of replay for this. It’s to the point where all these calls that get missed, cost people runs, cost people outs. Cost [starter Tommy Hunter] extra pitches.  I can’t say how I really feel but it’s pretty obvious.”

And here’s the umpire reactions
Jeff Kellogg (First base umpire and crew chief)

[on the play] “I went to the home plate umpire, who was coming up the line – Tim Timmons – I knew he was going to have a look at the edge of that bag coming up the line.”

Tim Timmons  (Home plate umpire)
“From when I saw the throw coming across, I knew that the throw was going to pull the first baseman that way. And at that point, that’s when I actually stopped and dropped anchor and looked for the foot. And when I saw the foot come up, the heel and the toe was on the bag. .. At the time he was going to glove the ball, when I saw the bottom of the whole foot and the foot dropped down onto the ground and I had daylight, I had him off the bag.”

“We just want to get the play right and that’s what we did there,” Kellog said. As to why he originally looked to Timmons, “The runner said something, the first base coach said something, [Tigers manager Jim] Leyland came out there.”


I would in no way call Timmons a liar, that would involve intention, but just as he attempted to watch the ball down the line in the 1st (as is his job), and ended up being so far out of position that he fell over Markakis while attempting to get into position at the plate, check the replay Tim. When you saw Reynolds’ foot coming down he’d had the ball for a few seconds. His foot didn’t go up into the air until after he left the bag “after” catching the ball. Also, how do you see a throw coming from “behind” you (Manny fielded the ball in foul territory) and know that the throw is going to take Reynolds off the bag? HIndsight is 20/20 and you’re just “lipservicing” your way through it. You guys shoulda done the Ravens game, ’cause you kicked calls all over the field. It’s hard enough playing the Tigers, but when they have extra players on the field, and they’re making the calls, it’s a daunting task for sure.

Go O’s!

Oh yeah and we always, as umpires change our calls when someone’s base coach complains. NOT!! He was right on top of the play so he defers to the other umpire who was nowhere near?? The first base umpire was NOT in the best position he could have been to make the call BUT he did get the call right. So if you have no more spine than that to make calls and cave in just because someone whines at you, you need to get a different job! Their home cooking umpiring was getting pretty obvious and they should be ashamed of the job they did. Plus by the rules, which wasn’t a judgement call, he chucks Reynolds out for throwing his glove down??? He should have been chucked out for not knowing the rules!

Thanks, Britt. Very nice reporting. From the umpiring, the 0-10 w/RISP, and the meatballs to Prince, this was a very frustrating night to be an O’s fan.

. You got the call wrong. As bad as it is, it happens. Just be a man and admit it. Rationalizing it makes you look pathetic.

Great Column!!

Timmons needs to learn from Jim Joyce. Enough said.

And Reynolds needs to learn from Armando Gallaraga.

I really thing they don’t like BUCK! They want him to fail . THE FANS ARE WATCHING!

More instant replay is coming and the clowns in the blue will have to live up to their mistakes right on the field. Wi know maybe some day we have one blue in the booth making all the calls and these guys can go back to being bus drivers. – (no offense tobus drivers)

Great idea! Football uses it Hockey uses it. Baseball still uses old fat guys for all close call decisions. Come on!

Pingback: Mark Reynolds blasts umpires following ejection | HardballTalk

So the umpires don’t want the Orioles in the playoffs since they can seemingly make whatever call they want, and MLB doesn’t want the Orioles in the playoffs either or they would have immediately begun looking into the matter. Hey MLB, are you aware that all questionable goals scored in the NHL are immediately reviewed by their league headquarters in Toronto? The technology exists…man up and use it! You say you want to get the calls right….then DO IT!

The umpires never have wanted the O’s in the postseason. Remember ’96? I applaud Mark for having the guts to say what he did. It’s about time the men in blue are held accountable for their actions.

Pingback: Orioles vs. Tigers lineups and pregame notes « Britt's Bird Watch

Pingback: Some Orioles quotes and thoughts « Britt's Bird Watch

It does seem that teams like the Yanks and Red Sox get these controversial calls go their way the majority of the time.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: